Mobitek System sells GSM Modem

 

Comparison Between MobiGATE and Short Code


FEATURES

SMS Gateway using MobiGATE

SMS Gateway using Short Code (ASP)

Asset

Tangible, all hardware and software belongs to client.

No tangible asset. Nothing belongs to client.

Ownership

Client owns the SMS Gateway.

Client does not own the SMS Gateway. The SMS Gateway is shared by all ASP's clients.

Initial Cost

High as client purchase the right to own hardware and software. One time payment.

Instead of outright purchase, client pays service fee for service rendered. Service fee is monthly (or yearly) payable.

Internet Connection
Not required.
Required, if the internet is down, then SMS cannot be send.

SMS Rate

  • outgoing SMS is charged according to network operator's plan

    • Maxis to Maxis/TimeCEL @ RM0.07

    • Celcom to Celcom @ RM0.05

    • Digi to Digi @ RM0.07

  • incoming SMS is free

  • outgoing SMS is more expensive, about RM0.20 per SMS send

  • receiving SMS is NOT free and requires a "keyword" for routing to the client's account

    • possibility of losing incoming SMS if it does not contain the correct keyword in order to route it to client's system.

SMS Number

Number depends on the SIM card used.
Client can request for a special number from operator, e.g. 018-8888888

  • 5 digit or more depending on the service provider or on the GSM network operator

  • the 5 digit short code is shared with other users, unless client purchase an unique short code

Speed of Sending SMS
and
Speed of Delivering SMS
Sending
The bottleneck is the GSM network which is 9.6kbps; speed is between 5 to 10 SMS per minute per SIM/channel.
For MobiGATE SG-4, 5 x 4 = 20 (to 40) SMS per minute
For MobiGATE SG-8, 5 x 8 = 40 (to 80) SMS per minute

Delivering
Instant

Sending
Depends on the Internet speed which is 1Mpbs, about few thousands SMS per minute


Delivering
Not instant, because the provider of short code will route the SMS to GSM network operator located in overseas (e.g. India) before coming back to local SMS Centre
Delivery Report
(
Delivery report will show whether the SMS is received by the recipient or not)
Yes
Usually No

Maintenance

  • If MobiGATE is down (for whatever reason), client's IT department can maintain and bring up the system again
  • need to pay maintenance fees
  • if SMS Gateway is down, client cannot do anything but wait


Security

  • client's database is located at client's local server; it is NOT stored externally

  • MobiGATE does not expose mobile numbers to any external parties

  • To send out SMS : user -> MobiGATE -> GSM network operator
    only the operator knows the mobile numbers

  • client's database is hosted/stored at provider of short code
  • the provider of short code has full control and access to database, and access to mobile numbers, messages sent, messages received, etc.

  • To send out SMS : user -> internet -> ASP-> Maxis -> recipient's mobile phone; total 4 steps. If internet is down, then SMS cannot be send out.   

 

Copyright Reserved